Author:
Publication: www.tehelka.com
Date: November 21, 2001
URL: http://www.tehelka.com/channels/currentaffairs/2001/nov/21/ca112101america.htm
Intelligence analysts Charles Brisard
and Guillaume Dasquie have released an explosive book that claims the US'
primary interest in the Afghan War might be oil, not terrorism; the US
president, they claim, had obstructed investigation into the Taliban's
terrorist activities, says V K Shashikumar
New Delhi, November 21
A book written by two French intelligence
analysts is certain to embarrass President George W Bush and his administration.
The book, Bin Laden, La Verite Interdite (Bin Laden, the Forbidden Truth),
released recently, claims that Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Deputy
Director John O'Neill resigned in July in protest over Bush's obstruction
of an investigation into Taliban's terrorist activities. The authors, Jean-Charles
Brisard and Guillaume Dasquie, claim that Bush resorted to this obstruction
under the influence of the United States' oil companies.
Bush stymied the intelligence agency's
investigations on terrorism, even as it bargained with the Taliban on handing
over of Osama bin Laden in exchange for political recognition and economic
aid. "The main obstacles to investigate Islamic terrorism were US oil corporate
interests, and the role played by Saudi Arabia in it," O'Neill reportedly
told the authors. According to the Brisard and Dasquie, the main objective
of the US government in Afghanistan prior to Black Tuesday was aimed at
consolidating the Taliban regime, in order to obtain access to the oil
and gas reserves in Central Asia.
Prior to September 11, the US government
had an extremely benevolent understanding of the Taliban regime. The Taliban
was perceived "as a source of stability in Central Asia that would enable
the construction of an oil pipeline across Central Asia" from the rich
oilfields in Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan, through Afghanistan
and Pakistan, to the Indian Ocean. This would have secured for the US another
huge captive and alternate oil resource centre. "The oil and gas reserves
of Central Asia have been controlled by Russia. The Bush government wanted
to change all that.this rationale of energy security changed into a military
one," the authors claim.
"At one moment during the negotiations,
US representatives told the Taliban, 'either you accept our offer of a
carpet of gold, or we bury you under a carpet of bombs'," Brisard said
in an interview in Paris. On Saturday, representatives of the Northern
Alliance (NA), former King Zahir Shah's confidantes, and possibly, non-Taliban
Pashtun leaders, will meet in Berlin under the aegis of the US-led coalition
to discuss a broad-based government in Afghanistan. It might be a coincidence
that the US and Taliban diplomatic representatives met in Berlin early
this year.
According to the book, the Bush
administration began a series of negotiations with the Taliban early in
2001. Washington and Islamabad were also venues for some of the meetings.
The authors claim that before the September 11 attacks, Christina Rocca,
in charge of Asian Affairs in the US State Department, met Taliban Ambassador
to Pakistan Abdul Salam Zaeef in Islamabad on August 2, 2001. Interestingly,
Rocca is a veteran of US involvement in Afghanistan. She was previously
in charge of contacts with Islamist guerrilla groups at the Central Intelligence
Agency (CIA), where she oversaw the delivery of Stinger missiles to Afghan
mujahideen fighting the Soviet occupation forces in the 1980s.
Brisard and Dasquie also reveal
that the Taliban were not really ultra-orthodox in their diplomatic approach,
because they actually hired an American public relations' expert for an
image-making campaign in the US. It is, of course, not known whether the
Pakistanis helped the Taliban secure the services of a professional image-maker.
What is, however, revealed in the book is that Laila Helms, a public relations
professional, who also doubles up as an authority on the way the US intelligence
agencies work, was employed by the Taliban. Her task was to get the US
recognise the Taliban regime. Prior to September 11, only three countries
- Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and UAE - recognised the Taliban regime. Helms'
familiarity with the ways of US intelligence organisations comes through
her association with Richard Helms, who is her uncle a former director
of the CIA and former US ambassador to Tehran.
Helms is described as the Mata Hari
of US-Taliban negotiations. The authors claim that she brought Sayed Rahmatullah
Hashimi, an advisor to Mullah Omar, to Washington for five days in March
2001 - after the Taliban had destroyed the ancient Buddhas of Bamiyan.
Hashimi met the Directorate of Central Intelligence at the CIA, and the
Bureau of Intelligence and Research at the State Department.
The Frenchmen have indeed produced
a controversial book, which is undoubtedly explosive, because of the interesting
nuggets of information they have dug up. Besides, they have an impressive
record in intelligence analysis, and this perhaps is the reason why the
book is being talked about in hushed tones in Paris and other European
capitals. Till the late 1990s, Brisard was the director of economic analysis
and strategy for Vivendi, a French company. He also worked for French secret
services (DST), and wrote for them in 1997 a report on the now famous Al
Qaeda network, headed by bin Laden. Dasquie is an investigative journalist
and publisher of Intelligence Online, a respected newsletter on diplomacy,
economic analysis and strategy.
On November 19, The Irish Times
said in a report, "O'Neill investigated the bombings of the World Trade
Center in 1993, a US base in Saudi Arabia in 1996, the US embassies in
Nairobi and Dar-Es-Salaam in 1998, and the USS Cole last year."
"Jean-Charles Brisard, who wrote
a report on bin Laden's finances for the French intelligence agency DST,
and is co-author of Hidden Truth, met O'Neill several times last summer.
He complained bitterly that the US State Department - and behind it the
oil lobby who make up President Bush's entourage - blocked attempts to
prove bin Laden's guilt."
"The US ambassador to Yemen, Barbara
Bodine, forbade O'Neill and his team of so- called Rambos (as the Yemeni
authorities called them) from entering Yemen. In August 2001, O'Neill resigned
in frustration, and took up a new job as head of security at the World
Trade Center. He died in the September 11 attack."
O'Neill, an Irish-American, reportedly
told Brisard that all the answers, and everything needed to dismantle bin
Laden's Al Qaeda, can be found in Saudi Arabia. Fearing that the Saudi
royal family would be offended, US diplomats quietly buried the leads developed
by O'Neill. So much so that even when the FBI wanted to talk to the suspects
accused of bombing a US military installation in Dhahran in June 1996,
in which 19 US servicemen were killed, the US State Department refused
to make much noise about it. The Saudi officials, however, interrogated
the suspects, declared them guilty and executed them. O'Neill actually
went to Saudi with his team, but according to the report in The Irish Times
quoting Brisard, "they were reduced to the role of forensic scientists,
collecting material evidence on the bomb site".
The US' hedging on investigating
Taliban's terrorist activities and its links with bin Laden were premised
on the belief that a quid pro quo deal could be arranged with Taliban.
The deal, apparently, was oil for diplomatic and international recognition.
One important reason for Operation Enduring Freedom could well be securing
American oil interests in the region. It would not be surprising if the
pipeline project is put back on track soon. Even a cursory look at the
oil potential of the Central Asian region is enough to understand the American
interest in this region. The Caspian Sea basin encompassing countries like
Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan are believed to possess
some 200 billion barrels of oil, which is about one-third the amount found
in the Persian Gulf area.
The greater Gulf area, encompassing
Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Oman, Saudi Arabia, the UAE and other adjacent countries,
has been a centre of international oil politics. First, the British fought
to gain control over the area's petroleum wealth, followed by the French.
But in the post-World War II scenario, the US emerged as the dominant power
in the region, because its energy security and economic prosperity depended
on the uninterrupted oil supply from this region. In March 1945, President
Franklin D Roosevelt and King Addel Aziz ibn Saud signed a secret agreement,
which forged a long-lasting strategic partnership. Though the details of
the agreement remains secret till date, the deal ensured privileged US
access to Saudi oil, in return for US protection of the royal family from
internal and external threats.
However, the US dependence on Middle
Eastern oil is not a secret. The US national energy policy, released by
the Bush administration earlier this year, stated, "The Gulf will be a
primary focus of US international energy policy." According to Michael
T Klare, professor of peace and world security studies at Hampshire College
in Amherst, and author of Resource Wars: The New Landscape of Global Conflict,
by launching Operation Enduring Freedom, the US want to achieve two sets
of objectives: "First, to capture and punish those responsible for the
September 11 attacks, and to prevent further acts of terrorism; and two,
to consolidate US power in the Persian Gulf and Caspian Sea area, and to
ensure continued flow of oil. And while the second set may get far less
public attention than the first, this does not mean that is any less important."
With many senior members of the
Bush administration linked to major oil business interests, it more than
a matter of coincidence that the US is involved in a war in Afghanistan.
Vice-President Dick Cheney was, until the end of last year, president of
Halliburton, a company that provides services for the oil industry. US
National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice was, between 1991 and 2000,
manager for Chevron; secretaries of commerce and energy, Donald Evans and
Stanley Abraham, worked for Tom Brown, another oil giant.
There is, therefore, more to the
War against terrorism than the Bush administration is willing to admit.
So, Operation Enduring Freedom wants to do the following:
Destroy Taliban and Al Qaeda;
Counter and destroy the threat
to Central Asian countries from Islamic extremists supported by bin Laden
and Taliban. The Americans have conducted joint military exercises with
forces of some Central Asian countries, and prior to start of the military
operations in Afghanistan, signed agreements of cooperation with Uzbekistan,
Tajikistan and Kyrgyzhstan; Negate the Taliban and Al Qaeda objective of
replacing the existing Central Asian governments with militant Islamic
regimes.
By achieving all these objectives,
Operation Enduring Freedom will also secure the US' oil interests in the
Caspian Sea area.
