Author: Charles Moore
Publication: The Telegraph, UK
Date: August 21, 2004
URL: http://www.opinion.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/main.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2004/08/21/do2101.xml&sSheet=/opinion/2004/08/21/ixopinion.html
One thing we are supposed to welcome
in modern Britain is "diversity". The theory is that the mixture of races,
cultures and religions which we have more and more become is a source of
strength and should therefore be nurtured and celebrated. Although there
is a great debate about how strong the overarching idea of Britishness
needs to be for the diversity to work, there is clearly much to be said
for the theory.
The authorities therefore set to
work to accommodate, within reason, the special requests of the minorities
- the observant Jew who wants to leave work on Friday in time for the beginning
of the Sabbath, the Hindu who cannot eat beef, the Muslim traffic warden
who does not want to wear a cap badge which includes the sign of the Cross.
Some of these questions can create
real difficulty - should the Cross, woven into so many national symbols,
such as the flag, which mean a great deal to us, really be sacrificed to
some people's feelings? But if the wish to be distinctive is genuinely
mixed with the desire to participate, then a way can usually be found.
So you might think it is good news
that "Islamic banking" is now taking hold. This month saw the launch of
Britain's first fully regulated and approved Sharia-compliant bank, the
Islamic Bank of Britain. And the big banks have also developed Islamic
banking arms. The need for these is said to arise because the Koran forbids
"riba", which is interest, or usury.
Yet Muslims need money and banks
need to make a living. Systems are devised to get round the ban. For example,
instead of a Muslim holding a mortgage for a house, the bank can own the
house and make arrangements for the Muslim gradually to buy it off the
bank over a period of years. HSBC now boasts of "Our Sharia Board" stuffed
with learned sheikhs and Justices from Arabia and Pakistan. Isn't all this
an encouraging example of how the resourcefulness of modern free societies
can achieve tolerance and market efficiency?
But when you look a little further
into the question of Islamic banking, you find that it is not, in fact,
required by Islam. Al-Azhar University, in Cairo, the main and ancient
home of Sunni religious learning, teaches that "riba" means extortionate
interest, not any interest at all, and that moderate interest should be
permitted. Most Egyptian banks charge and pay interest. Even Muslims who
reject this interpretation say that the doctrine of "extreme necessity"
permits Muslims in non-Muslim countries to pay interest.
So what is being proposed with Islamic
banking is actually a hardening of the religion, not an accommodation of
its existing custom. It is rather as if Catholics, arriving in large numbers
in a Muslim country, insisted that they must eat fish rather than meat
on a Friday, a rule which has been dropped by the Church in modern times.
And when you look at HSBC's Sharia Board you find that a couple of its
members have links with the Deoband, the long- standing ultra-conservative
group whose schools in Pakistan educated many of the Taliban.
Two others are Wahhabis, trained
by the intolerant and puritanical school of thought that dominates the
religious life of Saudi Arabia. If HSBC had a Christian Banking Board would
they staff it with disciples of the Rev Ian Paisley, the Rev Jerry Falwell
and the followers of the late Archbishop Lefebvre, rather than nice Dr
Rowan Williams or Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor?
I return to the question of diversity.
What happens if an important element of the mixture does not itself believe
in diversity, but solely in the advance of its own interest? I was very
struck by a remark of Sheikh Yusuf al-Qaradawi, the militant but apparently
mainstream theologian and supporter of suicide bombing, whose visit to
the Regent's Park mosque last month caused a fuss.
Justifying his view that all Israelis
are legitimate targets, he has declared: "Islam says that the majority
prevails on all and the rare has no rule." Reading and asking about this,
I find that although many, many Muslims would not apply this teaching to
the Israelis as he does, they do confirm that this attitude to the idea
of a minority is part of the religion.
Islam means "submission" (not "peace")
and it is the aim of Muslims ("those who have submitted") to make the whole
world submit. The teaching seems not to envisage the idea of Muslims as
a minority, except as a temporary phenomenon. The best that non-Muslims
- in Britain that means Sikhs and Hindus, as well as Jews and Christians
- can hope for is that they be treated as "dhimmis", second- class citizens
within the Islamic state.
Well, you might say, Christians
want the whole world to be Christian, so what is the difference? The difference
seems to lie in the attitude to politics. For many centuries now, Christians
have developed the idea that there is a separation between Church and state,
between what you may believe and what you may enforce. Islam does not seem
to have the same idea.
In a fascinating new research project
on Islam in modern Britain conducted by the Institute for the Study of
Islam and Christianity, the author, Patrick Sookhdeo, quotes from a best-selling
book put out by the influential and longstanding Muslim Educational Trust
called Islam: Belief and Teachings.
"Religion and politics," it says,
"are one and the same in Islam." Mohammed did not only preach in Mecca;
he also ruled in Medina, and he conquered. The Sharia is a code of law
to be imposed, in all societies, by the public authorities. It calls, among
other things, for apostates - those who have abandoned Islam - to be put
to death.
David Blunkett wants a law to prohibit
religious insult. He presumably does not see this as a step along the road
to item 295c of the Pakistan penal code, which makes defiling the name
of Mohammed punishable by death. But many Muslims would.
It does not necessarily follow that
most Muslims will try to impose their beliefs on this country by violence.
We see all around us the evidence of hundreds of thousands of people living
peacefully and productively with their neighbours. But it perhaps does
mean that we cannot just regard Islam in Britain as a charmingly exotic
addition to the English country garden.
According to its own beliefs, particularly
in their currently militant form, it is much more acquisitive.
Islam seeks an ever greater share
of the British public space. That is why Muslims were so keen on introducing
a religious question into the latest census, why they seek legal acceptance
of their marriage laws, and why they want state money for Muslim schools.
Once there are Islamic financial
institutions, how long will it be before Muslims insist that the state
and business direct all their monetary dealings with Muslims through these
institutions (boycotting businesses with Jewish connections en route)?
How long before Muslims, extending the logic of their concentration in
places like Bradford and Leicester, seek to establish their own law within
these areas, the germ of a state within a state? And how diverse would
such a state be?