Truth in Gujarat

Author: Balbir K Punj
Publication: The Pioneer
Date: April 24, 2002

For the last two months the "secular" pack and the media have been  busy weaving myths and half-truths following the carnage at Godhra  and its bloody backlash in the rest of Gujarat. Samples: These were  the worst riots in Gujarat; only Muslims were its victims; Sangh  Parivar and riots are synonymous; the Narendra Modi Government is  hounding the minorities and giving a free hand to the Hindu rioters;  Gujarat is still burning; etc. Pseudo-intellectuals have even termed  the riots as a "Pogrom of the minorities" and called shots at Modi  with words like "Hang the murderer".

Now, the facts. Out of 31,000 arrests made throughout the State in  connection of riots, 80 per cent are Hindus. Out of approximately  800 killed in Gujarat, one-fourth are Hindus. Out of 140 killed in  police firing, 80 were Hindus. Also, out of 100 killed in police  firing in the first three days, more than 70 were Hindus.

The secular pack is outraged over the "fact" that Gujarat, the land  of Mahatma Gandhi, which was an island of peace, has been set afire  after the emergence of the Sangh parivar as a dominant force. The  first part of the statement (regarding Gandhi) is half-true and the  rest is a total lie. No doubt Gandhi was born in Gujarat but so was  Jinnah, the father of Pakistan.

Now, the truth about the rest of the "secular" proposition.  Beginning from the 1714 Holi riots in the Mughal period, Ahmedabad  has witnessed no less than 10 major recorded riots. On September 18,  the last day of Urs celebrations in 1969, routine movements by cows  of Jagannath temple sparked off riots. An altercation took place  over the killing of a cow. An attack by 1,000-strong Muslim mob  snowballed into a historic riot in which 560 people were killed,  over 1,000 injured and thousands rendered homeless. The 1985 riots  over Rath Yatra procession were spread over a period of five months  from February to July. There was certainly no Sangh parivar in 1714,  and it was not a dominant force in 1969.

This brings us to another myth that riots are engineered by the  Sangh parivar. In other words, there should have been no communal  riots in India prior to the genesis of RSS in 1925. But history of  riots is older in the country. Was there a Sangh parivar in 1921,  when over 5,000 Hindus were killed by the Moplas of Malabar? Even  today, the cold blooded conspiracy for Godhra carnage is a chilling  reminder of Jinnah's call for Direct Action Day on August 16, 1946.  Between August 16 and 19, nearly 20,000 people perished on the  streets of Calcutta, with no succour till the vultures and kites  descended on the corpses.
 
The RSS was formed by a disciplined Congressman Keshavram Baliram  Hedgewar in 1925 at Nagpur in response to the support Congress  extended to the communal elements. For many years, its influence was  restricted to Maharashtra. So what explains riots in entire British  India from 1893 to 1947?

With a Muslim population of not less than 93 per cent, Kashmir  valley was no base for the RSS. Why, then, more than three lakh  Kashmiri Pandits were forced out of their homes and hearths to  become refugees in their own country? Have Muslims ever been forced  out of any part of India, including vast areas under Sangh parivar  domination? The secular pack would say that the Constitution and  rule of law did not allow the Parivar to do such a thing. How come  the same Constitution failed in Kashmir?

Fact is that the Parivar believes in Hindutva, based on equal  respect to all faiths.

The secularists have generally kept quiet about the plight of  Kashmiri Pandits, and, in fact, repeatedly extended support to  separatist elements in the Valley in the garb of protection of human  rights. When such secularists scream about riot victims in Gujarat  in a selective manner, their motives are obviously less than honest.

Similarly, the continuing exodus of Hindus and Chakma (Buddhist)  minorities from Bangladesh never pricked the conscience of the  secularists. In 1951, the Hindu population of Bangladesh (East  Pakistan) was 22 per cent, which dropped to 13.5 in 1974 and further  to 10.5 by 1991. Presently, it has touched 8 per cent - and Bangla  Hindus are likely to disappear in another 20 years - for the trend  seems irreversible.

Three million Hindus have left Bangladesh between 1974 and 1991 at  the rate of 375 persons a day. India also receives a high influx of  Muslim infiltrators from Bangladesh. They have altered the  demographic pattern of several bordering districts in Assam, Tripura  and Bangladesh. Any secularists protest over these developments?  None.

The secularists and the media claim to be speaking for democracy and  civil society. On the basis of a media trial, they want Mr Modi to  be hanged. Rather than allowing the elite ensconced in their air  conditioned offices in New Delhi, to sit in judgement on Mr Modi,  the BJP would like the people of Gujarat to give their verdict.  Those who oppose elections are "democratic" and those who are asking  for it are termed as "fascists". Since when has holding of elections  become undemocratic?
 
Still another canard being spread is that Mr Modi deliberately  delayed requisitioning the Army. In the past, Gujarat had seen riots  where a Congress Chief Minister took more than five days to call in  the Army. Mr Modi did so within 16 hours, at a time there was a  large and indefinite deployment of Army at India-Pakistan border.

One more myth is that Gujarat is still burning whereas the truth is  that the State is limping back to normalcy, notwithstanding the  provocative role of the secular pack and sporadic violent incidents.  There are enough hints to it.

From March 18 to 28, the first phase of SSC and HSC Board  examinations were carried out smoothly. Over 1.2 crore students  participated in various examinations throughout the State with an  average attendance of 98 per cent. Nearly 1,700 village panchayats  went to a fully incident-free polling on March 11 - the voters' turn  out was 75 per cent. The observance of Muharram with around 2,000  Tazia processions throughout the State went off peacefully. Holi was  completely peaceful. Around 6,000 Haj pilgrims returned to the State  in the meantime and were warmly welcomed in their villages.

Italy born Congress president Sonia Gandhi has emerged as the head  of the pack weaving "secular" myths. Nowadays, she is like a sponge,  erasing the gory past of 1984 anti-Sikh riots and soaking in the  future with dreams to lead the nation in the backdrop of Gujarat  carnage.

It does not bother her conscience that these myths and half-truths  have blackened India's image in the international community. I have  no doubt that truth shall triumph over the myths in the long run. I  can't help agree with Charles Darwin: "False views...do very little  harm, for everyone takes a salutary pleasure in proving their  falseness; and when this is done, one path towards error is closed  and the road to truth is often at the same time opened."
 


Back                          Top

This site is part of Dharma Universe LLC websites.
Copyrighted 2009-2011, Dharma Universe.