Was Antony true?

Author: Anish Nair
Publication: Sunday Kaumudi
Date: August 3, 2003
URL: http://www.sundaykaumudi.com/lookingb/look/lb_tpoint.stm

Reactions, over reactions and some finding an opportunity to take  the first flight to Delhi to complain. The drama was high after  Chief Minister A K Antony commented on the collective bargaining  by the minorities to get their needs. At times, truth will not  attractive. And unattractive truth will have many opposing it.

The feeling expressed by Antony has been brewing up among the  majority community for quite some time. Antony expressed this when  this feeling was moving towards an explosive level. The chief  minister asked the minority community to understand this feeling  before it turns to take a bad shape.

Though Antony did not mention any names, one community took up the  blame and began cry for CM's blood. Support was not far away as  many were waiting for such an opportunity to topple the  government. Added by 'concern' from major political parties Antony  was singled out. His arch rival and senior Congress leader sent  his emissary to Delhi to dictate terms.

A factor to note is that Antony never said that the rights of the  minorities should be taken away. Those who criticise him should  agree that with the help of constitution, Court order or  collective bargaining the minority communities have made their  presence prominent in many sector, especially the education  sector. This community feels that they are above the Government  when it comes to higher education. The present crisis in  self-financing colleges, regular Court visits seeking stay order  up to not attending meeting called by the Government, are a part  of it. The collective bargaining by the minorities were clearly  seen when almost 35 unaided schools were suddenly switched to  aided schools. The Chief Minister himself said that Maraad and  self-financing college issue forced him to make such a comment. No  cultural leaders or political parties severely condemned the  attacks. The reason was simple. All the killed were from the  majority community and words against the minority community will  cost their votes. Not long back newspapers carried the news that  the Government has withdrawn the criminal cases against six NDF  activists following a request from a Muslim League minister and  Kozhikode MLA and Antony had admitted the minister's role.

Naturally when the minority communities make such moves the  majority community feels their rights are unduly curbed. And this  fuelled the growth of, Bajrang Dal and various Hindu extremist  organisations.

If the majority community is given their rightful share, then it  is majority appeasement. Vice versa if the minorities demands  (whatever it may be) are met, then it's their rights. What a  predicament!! This structure will indeed sow seeds of hatred in  the community and this is exactly what Antony warned.

It may be tolerant attitude of the majority community that might  have prevented and outrage. But when pushed to the wall, things  can go from bad to worse. And this feeling is prevalent in the  majority of the people in the state. The NSS, SNDP and various  community organisations have welcomed CM's comments. They have  also requested Antony to put his words into practice.

Many inside his party as well as the Opposition were quick to  condemn Antony. The various left parties said that it was the  voice of the Sangh Parivar. A community leader said that Antony as  a chief Minister should never have made such a comment.

Every ruler should have the courage and will to speak the truth.  Like the majority community the minorities too should take care to  crate a peaceful atmosphere in the state. Or of they feel they are  humiliated to the extend, withdraw support to Antony government  and seek fresh mandate.

Either way, the truth behind Antony's comment will not change even  if he withdraws or to the extend, resigns.
 


Back                          Top