HVK Archives: An agenda for tomorrow
An agenda for tomorrow - The Free Press Journal
M V Kamath
()
14 August 1997
Title: An agenda for tomorrow
Author: M V Kamath
Publication: The Free Press Journal
Date: August 14, 1997
A few years ago the editor of a south Indian daily re quested me to write a
weekly article for him as he considered I had something useful to say on
contemporary affairs. I readily complied with the request. A few weeks
later, however, he stopped publishing them. When I enquired about the
matter I was somewhat sheepishly told that ten per cent of the paper's
readership objected to my writings.
Somewhat surprised, I asked whether I had written anything objectionable
about the "ten per cent" or had otherwise offended their sensibilities. I
was assured that I had done nothing of the sort. Had I, further queried,
hurt their religious feelings? No. I hadn't, came the reply. Then I asked
whether the editor had sought to find out the views of the other 90 per
cent of his readers who apparently read me with interest. There was no
reply. I discontinued my column. I had all but forgotten the incident when,
a few months later, the "ten per cent" went on the offensive, attacked the
newspaper office, smashed costly equipment and decamped without a trace. It
was a relief to me to know that at least I was not to be blamed for
whatever the "ten per cent" was worked up about.
A couple of weeks ago I wrote to the editor of another journal inquiring
whether he would be interested in my writing a series of articles on the
Great Mughals, based on a newly published book under the same title that
provided some fascinating information Babar and his descendants. I was told
that the articles would be welcome but, please, will I take care not to be
controversial?
I decided that I would rather not write anything at all.
A few weeks ago the offices of Asian Age in Bangalore were ransacked by
hooligans, generally believed to belong to a minority community allegedly
because the paper published some news concerning the desecration of the
Prophet's name somewhere in Israel. The same minority community, it may be
remembered, had raided the offices of the Bangalore-based Deccan Herald
wreaking damages worth a few lakhs of rupees, a year or two ago. These
incidents, sporadic as they are, raise certain important questions. Is it
ever possible for a rational dialogue between the two communities as to
their respective attitudes towards each other? Can Hindus, for instance,
state without any hang-ups as to what they feel deep down about nine
hundred years of Islamic rule in India? Can they express their anguish or
angst at what they perceive to be centuries of oppression and religious
intolerance?
Matters are complicated by the attitude adopted not so much by leaders of
the minority community but by Hindu intellectual liberals who largely
dominate the academic scene in this country. Their approach to all
Hindu-Muslim problems' can be summarised thus:
Muslim tyranny towards Hindus is a myth fostered by British historians. Or
Muslim rulers are not really that bad as have been depicted. Or
Medieval rulers were all alike, whether they were Muslims or Hindus. Or
So what if they were tyrannous? Were Hindu rulers any better? Or
Why do we have constantly to bark back on the past? Or
Those who speak of Islamic misrule are communal-minded and fascists. Or
Haven't the upper castes ill-treated the lower castes? What business do
they have to complain against Islam?
At that point all discussion ceases. Anger festers inside the hearts. And
the end result is something like the destruction of the Babri Masjid. If
only the Muslim community had the magnanimity or the compassion to
understand what goes on in the Hindu mind, the Babri Masjid, instead of
being demolished, could have merely been dismantled and rebuilt at some
other location, the credit accruing to both the communities. When this was
pointed out to Syed Shahabuddin on a Doordarshan talk show, his instant
reaction was to say that the Muslims will not surrender. The fact of the
matter is that Hindus and Muslims have not yet come to terms with their
history. Partition did not achieve that objective. It merely postponed it.
In India there persists unresolved tensions between the two communities
and the electricity has to be earthed for the good of both. This is not
happening. On the other hand, the tendency is to resort to abuse. Anyone
who speaks up in favour of Ram Janmabhoomi is immediately dubbed a
communalist, a fascist and a Nazi, if not worse. There is no room for
understanding.
So much for Hindu-Muslim relations. If we look into the affairs of Hindus
themselves the picture is no better. The subject of caste comes up and the
tyranny exercised by upper caste Hindus over the lower castes, is
prominently raised. Here again the upper castes beat a hasty retreat,
rather than face the issue boldly and squarely. Worse, they resort to such
cheap gimmicks such as lionising lower caste 'heroes'. Dr. Bhimrao
Ambedkar, for instance, is raised to near divinity. Large-sized statues
are raised in his honour, a larger-than-life size painting is hung in
Parliament a Bharat Ratna is bestowed on the man and the Government goes to
the extent of naming the leader's birthday as a national holiday. None of
which, of course, meets the real issue which is detoxicating caste
relationships. This is hypocrisy of the worst order.
The usual approach is one of letting sleeping dogs lie or in believing that
if one ignores a problem it will go away of its own accord. The liberal,
intellectual Hindu does not want to be bothered with inconvenient issues
that only disturbs his peace. Why worry about the past, goes his attitude,
when it is more important to thinking of the future? But the past, like
Banquo's ghost, will not just disappear. Both Hindus and Muslims on the
one hand, and upper and lower castes Hindus on the other have got to come
to terms with it. There is no easy way out.
The Babri Masjid 'imbroglio' if such it can be called was the inevitable
backlash of a historic angst that has gone unresolved. It may warm the
cockles of liberal, secular, intellectual hearts to dismiss those who tore
down the Babri Masjid as barbarians, fascists etc. But how has that helped
to usher in a better understanding between Hindus and Muslims? The
ceaseless deification of Dr. B. R. Ambedkar has had its reaction in the
shape of a well-argued and researched book by Arun Shourie under the title
Worshipping False Gods. With expected fury, some politicians have burnt a
copy of the book as if that will exorcise the devil within us. What Shourie
has done is to force us to look at ourselves and our hypocrisies. He is
telling us in plain language that lionising Dr. Ambedkar, bestowing on him
a Bharat Ratna etc. etc. does not meet the issue. What meets the issue is
the fair and honest acceptance of the fact that injustice has been done and
must be atoned for. What shape that atonement must take is something for
discussion and debate. Islamic misrule for almost a thousand years, the
sustained assault on Hinduism often carried out with barbaric brutality -
or why would a Guru Gobind Singh dare to take on the might of the Mughal
Raj? - can be forgiven, but not forgotten. It can, however, be forgiven
only if its ferocity and viciousness is seen as such and a sense of remorse
shown. To argue that the chattering classes have no desire to dwell on the
past is to duck the issue and exhibit a cowardice that is so painfully
evident. Much the same can be said of the upper castes whose record is no
cleaner. A clear message has to go to the lower castes that the upper
castes have criminally blundered and efforts will be made to clean up Hindu
society as a whole. The wise would know that this is not- something that
can be done overnight. It is going to be a long-drawn process, but the
commitment must be seen as a functioning one. It is only then that the
years to come will see a united and more harmonious India.
Confrontation and accession will have to make place for cooperation and
understanding "Social justice" as Arun Shourie rightly points out in his
book, "today is nothing but a cover for out-and-out casteist politics".
'Dalits' has become a pass-word for, indeed the justification for abuse,
aggression. Shourie says: "And such is the condition of our society, in
particular of those who control public discourse and of our political
leaders, that no one speaks about the poison which is being spread in the
name of 'backwards' and 'dalits'. It is this ideology which has spawned so
many of our current troubles. An ideology in which, as Ortega Gasset would
have said, mediocrity is the norm, vulgarity is the right, in which
standards are an elitist conspiracy, in which civility and reason are the
veneer of the well-to-do, in which intimidation is argument, and assault is
proof?'. Is this the kind of society that out liberal want? Shourie again
writes: "Among the liberal this ideology has become the rationalisation for
capitulation. And among the leaders of so-called Dalits and OBCs and of the
Muslims, it has become the justification for 'direct action'. Unless the
ideology is rolled back, the problems that plague us will intensify no end..."
If we want a fair society in the second half of a century of our nation's
life of independence, we must be free to speak out boldly, recognise the
damage done in the past without fear or favour, whether by Islamic rule or
upper caste 'touch-me-not-ism' and thereby set the foundation of the
national united in spirit and purpose. But first the fear among us must be
eliminated. We must look the past in its face and promise ourselves that
the future will be different. To insist that there is nothing wrong in the
past is to concede that we will do nothing better in the future. Surely, as
a wise people we know the difference?
Back
Top
|