White lies and not-so-white accusations
White lies and not-so-white accusations
Author: Shyam Khosla
Publication: The Organiser
Date: May 7, 2000
The Rashtriya Swayamsevak
Sangh has been the target of anti-Hindutva elements for long. The mischief
began with the totally false and politically motivated allegation of RSS'
involvement in the assassination of the Mahatma. Those occupying responsible
positions in the Government and political life of the country never miss
an opportunity to throw mud at the patriotic organisation engaged in character
building and national unity even though numerous judicial commissions appointed
by the Government to fix responsibility for the dastardly assassination
have exonerated the Sangh. The malicious campaign against the RSS and organisations
inspired by it was intensified with the BJP coming to power at the Centre.
The objective obviously is to destabilise the Vajpayee Government by sowing
seeds of discord between the BJP and its allies.
One would have laughed
away the distortions and blantant lies resorted to by the 'secular' brigade
if their design was not so sinister and if their vicious campaign had not
sullied the nation's image so badly. English-language media is in the fore-front
of this campaign of vilification in its blind opposition to the Hindutva,
little realising that its distortions and lies are projecting a very negative
image of the country and enabling anti-Indian forces to malign our glorious
tradition of religious tolerance. Let us examine a few distortions and
lies spread in recent weeks.
Hate campaign
In one of his public
addresses after taking over as the Sarsanghchalak, Shri Sudarshan traced
the ideological conflict between the Hindutva philosophy and Western thought
and asked the nation to be prepared for an "epic war" between Hindutva
and anti-Hindutva forces. No sane person can interpret it to be anything
but an ideological conflict between two civilisations. But the secularists
chose to ministerpret it as a "call for an epic war between Hindus and
non-Hindus". Columnists and editorial writers lost no time in castigating
the RSS chief for spreading communalism and inciting communal violence.
No one bothered to check with the RSS or carefully read the text of Sudarshan's
public address. It is hard to believe that these intellectuals could not
differentiate between an ideological conflict and a communal flare-up.
It cannot be dismissed as a case of misunderstanding based on lack of communication.
It is a clear case of sick minds distorting facts to intensify the hate
campaign against the Sangh.
Not only that, there
has been a spate of slanderous editorials in English-language newspapers
over "attacks on Christians in UP and Haryana". Did any of these newspapers
send one of its senior reporters to the spot to dig out the truth or did
they merely rely on the rumour mills run by the John Dayals and others
of his ilk? Some of the dailies that call themselves national projected
road accidents and robberies as Bajrang Dal's attacks on minorities showing
scant regard for truth.
Facts speak for themselves
What are the facts? The
road accident in Haryana was highlighted by major dailies as "attacks on
Christians" in utter disregard to easily verifiable details of the case
and even the version put out by officials and Christian leaders of Rewari.
According to the Deputy Commissioner of Rewari, Smt Sumita Misra Singh,
around 11.15 p.m. on April 22, three nuns going towards the church in Rewari
were hit from behind by a scooter number DL-2CK-5604. The scared driver
ran away leaving behind his vehicle. One of the nuns, Sister Anandi, after
being treated at the Civil Hospital was shifted to the Holy Family Hospital
in Delhi as she had received head injuries and needed a CT scan. An FIR
was registered and the scooterist has been identified.
Father Philip Parmar
of the Pallki Purohit Catholic Church, and Sr. Ludmilla De Souza Mother
Superior of Deepti Ashram to which the nuns belonged, have in a signed
statement deplored the attempts by certain vested interests to give a communal
colour to the accident. These elements, they regretted, were trying to
create a wedge between the Christians and Hindus residing in the town.
There was complete amity among the people of Rewari and these vested interests
were unnecessarily spreading venom of hatred by projecting an accident
as an attack on Christians. "The misinformation campaign appears to be
a part of a conspiracy", they added. Yes, Fr. Philip and Sr. De Souza.
You are right. You have hit the nail on the head. It is indeed a part of
a vicious conspiracy. For proof, see how the National Spokesman of All
India Christian Council,
John Dayal reacted. He condemned the accident as the fifth attack on Christians
in Haryana.
Communalising a robbery
The robbery at Kosi Kalan
in Mathura district of UP where robbers looted a school and attacked the
Father and a Sister of St Theresa School has too been communalised. Raghuvir,
who runs a PCO in the neighbourhood, rushed to the school with friends
to rescue the injured Father. The police too arrived but the robbers made
good their escape. An FIR was promptly registered and the police are on
the lookout for two antisocials-Nanhe Miyan and Sher Ali-who are allegedly
involved in several crimes committed in the town in recent weeks and are
suspected to be involved in this crime as well. While the police are looking
for the robbers, the secularists have already decided that it is a part
of the campaign to terrorize minorities.
The Agra incidents involving
the management of the St Paul School and St John's Degree College pertain
to the excesses committed by the managements on non-Christians. In one
of these incidents, the victim. Sarita Singh, a student of St John's College,
was under pressure from a teacher and a clerk of the college to get converted
to Christianity. She was harassed when she declined. The second victim,
Snehlata, is a school teacher, who was attacked at a public place by the
persons managing the St Paul School. She was beaten up and her clothes
were torn. On her complaint, the police took three accused (all Christian
missionaries) belonging to the school into custody. They were later let
off under pressure from
local politicians. The
secularists proclaimed these incidents to be "attacks on Christians".
St Dominic School and
Sacred Heart School of Mathura were involved in disputes with parents of
students. There were clashes between the school authorities and parents
over admission to the former school and steep hike in fees by the latter.
Local leaders of the Congress, CPI and the BSP led the campaign against
the management of the Sacred Heart School. These conflicts had no political
or communal overtones. But these details are not relevant for the Secularists
who lost no time in launching a tirade against Hindu organisations for
"harassing minorities and targeting Christian institutions".
Minorities Commission
The Minorities Commission
has expressed displeasure over the falsehood spread by vested interests
with regard to the Mathura incidents. Justice Mohammed Shamim, Chairman
of the Minorities Commission, led a five-member team to Mathura to investigate
the incidents. He also visited the St Theresa School, Kosi Kalan, that
had been attacked by robbers. The Commission spoke to the parties concerned
and came to the conclusion that these incidents had no communal overtones
and commanded the local, people for playing a positive role in dealing
with the unfortunate incidents.
The only incident in
UP in which Bajrang Dal had some role to play is the one in which angry
villagers of Nagla Ajeeta near Agra burnt some literature brought to their
village by a 14-member group of missionaries from Hyderabad. The Bajrang
Dal's charge is that the group was seeking to convert people by offering
them money. It caused an FIR to be lodged with the police. The missionaries'
version is that the villagers led by Dal volunteers attacked them and burnt
some literature they had brought to distribute among the villagers. The
police have already arrested six persons in connection with the complaint
lodged by the missionaries and the Commissioner of Bareilly is conducting
an enquiry into the incident. But there is no end to secularist mischief.
The "literature" burnt by villagers suddenly became "biblical literature"
and to top it all one English-language newspaper reported that it was the
Bible that was burnt down. The secularists can cook up enough explosive
material to stoke communal passions.
No time for drought
Sonia Gandhi, who chose
not to participate in the discussion on the unprecedented drought in several
parts of the country, was so moved by the "attacks on Christians" that
she delivered a passionate speech in the Lok Sabha to denounce the government
for its failure to protect the minorities. Votebank practitioners closed
ranks in Parliament to mount a bitter attack on RSS and Bajrang Dal for
the incidents in Haryana and UP. These stray incidents, including an accident
and a robbery, were painted as a "premeditated and perverse plan hatched
by Bajrang Dal to eliminate the minorities", Congress MP, Jaipal Reddy,
assailed Bajrang Dal as a terrorist organisation and demanded that it be
banned. CPM leader Somnath Chatterjee said these were not isolated incidents
and a "jehad" had been unleashed against the minorities. SP Supremo Mulayam
Singh said minority communalism was "less dangerous".
While demanding action
against the guilty, BJP leader V.K. Malthotra turned the tables on the
secularists by pointing out that the Opposition remained silent when Hindus
were killed in J&K and elsewhere. He accused the Opposition of a conspiracy
of silence on provocative speeches and actions by fundamentalists among
minorities. In this context, he referred to the deplorable declaration
by Imam Bukhari of Delhi's Jama Masjid that he was an agent of ISI.
The 'secular' media too
played its role to the hilt. Editorial writers poured venom on the Hindu
organisations blaming them for 'attacks' on Christians without caring to
verify the facts. What is more painful is that those who know that patently
false charges have been levelled against Hindu organisations to malign
and discredit them either remain silent or join the 'secular' chorus of
condemnation. Ministers in the NDA Government too do not bother to gather
credible information through official and non-official sources to get to
the truth and routinely condemn all so-called attacks on minorities. The
extremely efficient and well-oiled propaganda machinery of the missionaries
seems to have put them on the defensive. Who will expose the falsehood
being spread against Hindu organisations?
Back
Top
|