Author: Saisuresh Sivaswamy
Publication: Rediff
on Net
Date: November 28, 2000
What do you do when someone
has unleashed untold violence against you, your family, covets what is
yours and tries to destroy everything that is dear to you? I pretty well
know what I would do. First I would try and sort out this trouble-maker
through legal intervention, but knowing the kind of time and effort, not
to mention outcome, such a course would claim, I would at the same time
explore other avenues to eliminate this spot of trouble by other means.
Creating a favourable
public opinion could be an option, but since fights are best won when fought
on equal turf, and also since the violators of civil norms seldom follow
principles, this is not a course of action I would waste my energies on.
Luckily, since I live
in Mumbai, a city that has a parallel mechanism to dispense quick and effective
justice, if my troubles continue I would try and sort out my woes on my
own through such a system.
Why would I do that?
'Cos I love what is mine, and will defend it to the best of my ability.
As, I believe, will anyone who is pushed into a corner.
As individuals, all of
us have a vision about how we will react in such pressure situations; and
also a vision of how we would like our nation to react when confronted
by a similar situation.
What I would like India
to do, when its being is threatened, internally or at the borders, is to
use the instruments of state at its disposal to neutralise the challenge.
By all means take the soft way, but by no means suspend its right and resolve
to combat the evil in the manner it sees fit.
If an assailant is worrying
me, the last thing I would do is to cease taking any action against him
during, say, Lent in order to show my respect for his religious sentiments.
Nor, I am sure, will you. And surely, when religious extremists are
bleeding my country to death, I would not want my country to display a
grandiose gesture that is worthy of none else than the Mahatma, may his
soul rest in peace.
I would not allow my
son to have sporting encounters with the blackguard who is destroying my
family's peace and then justify it by saying that sports shouldn't interfere
with other aspects of life -- and I am sure you will not act differently
either.
And that is also the
precise way I would expect my country to behave in a similar situation
-- again, as I am sure do you.
Since what we want for
ourselves, and what we all want for our country, are the same, frankly
I am puzzled as to how the government of the day has had the gumption to
assume the public's mandate for behaving differently from what they want.
When the terrorists are
running amok in Kashmir, when they have displayed no compassion whatsoever,
when they massacre pilgrims, when they have rejected the notion of India,
I am quite clear in my mind how I want my India to react to the challenge.
Not by offering a unilateral
ceasefire to mark the 'holy month of Ramzan' (for heaven's sake!).
The men who are waging war against India are beyond humanity, religion,
and are a bunch of nihilists; to associate the country's second largest
faith with them is giving a bad name to those Muslims of India who have
nothing to do with the war being waged in their name and for who, I am
sure, associating the ceasefire with their holy month would be nothing
short of anathema.
When agents provocateur
are playing ducks and drakes with India's future, then any Indian would
expect his country -- ie, those who take decisions affecting his country's
destiny -- to behave in the exact manner that an Indian would react if
it was his house that was being plundered.
A ceasefire, in my sense,
would make sense if the Indian security forces had been able to break the
back of militancy and the terrorists were on the run. For peace can
be won only from a position of strength, as K P S Gill will testify readily.
Right now what the ceasefire will amount to is giving time for the terrorists
to recoup and launch a more energetic assault against India at the end
of the one-month break in hostilities that we have conceded them out of
our love for their wellbeing. If Salahuddin and his cronies laugh
all the way to jannat, I am sure they will pass on some benediction down
to the mortals responsible for such a bold decision. Perhaps wish
the Nobel Peace Prize on them...
Cricket in the time of
war?! That surely should provide our film-makers with ample scope for ideas;
after all, the border areas of the country have never received so much
attention from the entertainment industry as it is doing now, so maybe
the time is ripe for another potboiler, this one dealing with the trauma
of a cricket star separated from his fan across the border thanks to the
subcontinent's politics. Throw in a couple of fight sequences, at
least one 'item' number, and a climax set in the Gaddafi stadium...
If you think that that
paragraph trivialised what is going on in Kashmir today, what do you make
of the chorus gaining ground that the aborted India-Pak series should go
on? On one hand India is making out a case with the United States and other
arbiters in such cases for declaring Pakistan a terrorist country, for
what it is doing to us in Kashmir and elsewhere. On the other, a
section of the establishment actually believes there is a lot to be gained
from playing cricket and other sports with our malevolent neighbour.
If Russia and America, who did not have the kind of overtly violent history
that plagues this region, stayed off sporting encounters at the height
of the Cold War, should India even waste its time deliberating on such
non-issues?
Actually, a lot of what
I have to say on the topic has been said before. Consistency, it
is said, is the virtue of fools, but where it comes to Pakistan and Kashmir
I would prefer being a fool than being sorry.