Author: N. S. Rajaram
Publication: Organiser
Date: September 23, 2001
Introduction: Terrorism is a global
phenomenon that calls for a global response. But first the ideology behind
terrorism must be understood, observes N. S. Rajaram.
Pearl Harbour revisited
In its enormity the terrorist attack
on the New York World Trade Center and the Pentagon has been compared to
the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbour.
It is actually worse. The Pearl
Harbour attack was by a military force on a military base. The World Trade
Center attack was a typical act of cowardice favoured by terrorists-attack
on a soft target filled with unarmed and unsuspecting civilians. This is
what the Pakistani terrorists have been doing in Jammu and Kashmir for
years, which the West including America has turned a blind eye to. The
attack was in some ways similar to the bombing of the Bombay Stock Exchange
in 1993, only greatly more destructive. The level of planning and organization
that went into the WTC attack was also much greater. This shows that there
exists a formidable Islamic terrorist network in the United States and
beyond.
This brings up a basic point: Why
have the Western countries, US in particular, failed to learn from the
Indian experience? Even worse, why has the US continued to sponsor and
promote countries like Pakistan with well established record of sponsoring
terrorist outfits like the Taliban and sheltering criminals like Dawood
Ibrahim? There was no lack of evidence. A few years ago the World Trade
Center was bombed by an Islamic group; and a couple of CIA operatives were
killed by Pakistanis. But none of this alerted the US to the possibility
of major terrorist attacks on targets on American soil. Even after the
Bombay Stock Exchange bombing, it did not strike American experts that
what happened in Mumbai could also happen in New York.
All this suggests an insular state
of mind that refuses to learn from the experience of open societies like
India that have faced similar problems.
There is an implicit assumption
that such things can happen in India, but never in the United States. Professor
Daniel Pipes, a leading expert on Islamic terrorism recently wrote in The
Wall Street Journal (September 12):
"The tactical blame (for the attack
on WTC) falls on the U.S. Government, which has grievously faded in its
topmost duty to protect American citizens from harm. Specialists on terrorism
have been aware of this dereliction of duty; now the whole world knows
it. Despite a steady beat of major, organized terrorist events over 18
years (since the car bombing of the U.S. embassy in Beirut in 1983), Washington
has not taken the in" seriously."
Intellectual failure
In his article, Prof. Pipes highlights
a failure to comprehend the ideological basis of fundamentalist terror:
"Not understanding the hate-America mentality" of Islamic terrorists. "Buildings
like the World Trade Center and the Pentagon loom very large as symbols
of America's commercial and military presence "around the world." There
is a similar 'hate-Hindu' mindset, which makes Islamic terrorists target
Hindu symbols like the Amarnath yatra.
The secular-humanist West has difficulty
comprehending, this faith-based phenomenon. Indian intellectuals, with
their great experience of Islam should be of help, but with ram exceptions
they have failed to meet the challenge. Even worse, many have turned apologists
by diverting attention to imaginary targets like "Hindu communalism". This
came to the fore immediately after the World Trade Centre attacks, when
some in the media sensing that Pakistan would be a major suspect, indulged
in sophistry. The day after the attacks, The Times of India in its front
page editorial claimed that "so-called Islamic fundamentally might falsely
be blamed and darkly hinted that South American narcotics smugglers might
be responsible. Another editorial realised that Taliban was the culprit
without mentioning that Taliban is a creation of Pakistan. In an interview
of Shri L K Advani, Rajdeep Sardesai of Star TV expressed concern that
there was danger of 'generalization from Islamic terrorism, mewing that
Muslims might be blamed for it. Perhaps non-Muslims should be blamed for
Islamic terror. The situation is not much better in the West. In his first
public statement after the terrorist attacks, the British Prime Minister
Tony Blair gratuitously asserted that such attacks go against the teachings
of Islam. This reflects a serious problem relating to poor understanding
of Islam in the West. Much of the blame lies in Western academia. There
is no shortage of departments of Oriental Studies, Middle Eastern Studies,
South Asian Studies and so forth, but they are mainly filled with Islamic
apologists. Until recent events brought it to the fore, any discussion
of Jihad in the context of violence was taboo. As Walter Laquer, a leading
American expert on terrorism observed: "They [Islamists] claim dust Islam
is a highly moral religion, espousing love rather than hate, and is pluralist
and democratic in inspiration. Because of this energetic defense, it has
become almost taboo to discuss terrorism in the Islamic context."
The problem is particularly acute
in the various South Asia Studies departments in the United States. They
are filled with Marxists and other anti-Hindus who have kept up a drumbeat
of anti-Hindu rhetoric that has made a serious study of Islam all but impossible.
Academics in these departments, some of them of Indian origin, are turning
out worthless tracts, whose main theme is a relentless attack on Hinduism
and its history, often grotesquely misrepresenting the truth. As a result,
any policy maker or even serious student looking for information about
the record of Islam in India has nowhere to go.
The situation is not much different
in the Indian academia. Any scholar or even writer discussing Jihad in
the context of Islamic terror is at once denounced as a 'communalist',
the worst swearword there is in the Indian intellectual vocabulary. Rare
is the academic or scholar who can -survive this kind of attack. What they
have produced so far is comparable in value and relevance to D. N. Jha's
recent book on beef eating. Thus, major source of knowledge in the world's
battle against Islamic terror has been almost totally suppressed. It represents
a monumental failure of vision and professionalism and a missed opportunity
of historic proportions. These men and women will end up in the dustbin
of history.
Terrorism as a belief system
The need of the hour is a clear
understanding of the belief system or she ideology that underlies Islamic
terror. This is available in India from two sources. First, the works of
non-establishment scholars and publishers like Sita Ram Goel and Voice
of India. Next, the works of Islamic authors themselves, especially those
put out by the sponsors of terror. It must be said to the credit of the
latter that they have made no secret of their goal of spreading their influence
through terror. The seminal work The Quranic Concept of War by Brigadier
S. K. Malik, sponsored by the late General Zia unequivocally states that
Jihad, "the most glorious word in the vocabulary of Islam ... is a continuous
and never-ending struggle waged on all fronts."
But the doctrine goes further to
encompass the whole world: "It was the cause of humanity in general and
not just the Muslim community in particular."
It is a universal doctrine, to be
applied to the whole world.
What is extraordinary in all this
is the central role assigned to terror. "The Quranic military strategy
thus enjoins us to prepare ourselves for war to the utmost in order to
strike terror into the heart of the enemy, known or hidden, while guarding
ourselves from being terror-stricken by the enemy." Even more, "Terror
struck into the hearts of the enemy is not only a means, it is the end
in itself. Once a condition of terror into the opponent's heart is obtained,
hardly anything is left to be achieved... Terror is not a means of imposing
decision upon the enemy; it is the decision we wish to impose upon him."
That is to say, the enemy is to live in a state of perpetual terror. This
is needed to bring justice and freedom from oppression.
Pakistan has put this terror doctrine
into practice in its proxy war in Kashmir. This has now been extended to
the American soil. It is of paramount importance to recognize that Islamic
terrorists are acting under the firm belief that they can achieve their
goals through terror. This means terror is everything- strategy, tactics
and ideology using religion as cover. Unless the world recognizes this
basic truth, mere military strikes against a few targets will achieve little.
US in particular must shed its insularity and learn from the experience
of other societies.