Author:
Publication: Rediff on Net
Date: June 6, 2005
Advaniji, yeh aapne kya kiya, kyon
kiya? (Advaniji, why did you do this?)
Bharatiya Janata Party chief Lal
Kishenchand Advani has kicked up a storm by calling Mohammed Ali Jinnah,
the founder of Pakistan, a man of impeccable secular credentials. The statement
made in Pakistan just a couple days after Advani dumped the Sangh Parivar's
'Akhand Bharat' theory, is being seen by some in his party and the Parivar
as a betrayal.
For them the unthinkable has happened.
All these years Advani and other BJP leaders questioned the logic of Partition
and held Jinnah primarily responsible for India's division. BJP workers
are suddenly unable to come to terms with their chief's change of stand.
Advani's 'I don't hate Pakistan' line has left them cold.
Senior Editor Sheela Bhatt met one
such party worker who has worshipped Advani all these years. But his leader's
visit to Jinnah's mausoleum in Karachi and his statement there glorifying
the man, he said, has left him seething.
"I am a BJP soldier and I never
anticipated such a situation where our strongest leader will harm the cause
of Hindus. I just want to tell you that not only BJP voters but Indians
by and large do not agree with my leaders' views on Jinnah."
This is the BJP soldier's open letter
to a leader he calls his senapati (commander):
Dear Advaniji,
How can you speak like this? We
didn't expect such a melodramatic u-turn from you. We always understood
Vajpayeeji [former prime minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee]. He was a moderate.
Many a time we didn't agree with his liberal views, but since he loved
us and he loved our party, we ignored his statements.
I am your solider. You were my senapati
(commander). You have betrayed your soldiers. I am very hurt because in
the last ten years, while serving the BJP day and night, I never thought
even once that Advaniji could betray the Hindus. Do you know a few people
from our party have sent you a message expressing our strong disagreement?
They have said in the message that 'Ishwar na karen yeh khabar sach ho'
(may the reports of your utterances on Jinnah be untrue). I want to say
again and again that crores of Hindus have been hurt by your remarks.
Advaniji, what image we carried
of you in our hearts! And now, after your Pakistan visit, I can't find
the words to describe how I feel. I don't know why you have changed your
politics and your thinking. But this is not good for the health of our
party. In India no one knew about your plan to change your heart in Pakistan!
We were surprised to hear this news from across the border.
We are shocked. Our leaders in the
party offices are shaken. They are not ready to talk to us. They are saying
let's wait and watch. You will have to explain. Why have you suddenly decided
to change the party's thinking of past 58 years? Have you forgotten everything
that Jinnah did? Yesterday one of our leaders told us that how Jinnah remained
unmoved even after 90,000 Hindu women were raped on the eastern borders.
Vulgar remarks were scribbled on our women's bodies. Have you forgotten
all these injustices?
Advaniji, I am told that you became
emotional on reaching your family house [in Karachi]. When I go to my native
place, I too become nostalgic. I wish this is nothing more than nostalgia
and you will come back to your real self.
You forgot your politics and you
forgot your party on reaching Karachi. If that is the truth, we will come
to terms with it. Somebody told us you were misled by former Communist,
Sudheendra Kulkarni [national secretary and secretary to the party president],
who doesn't know much about our party.
I feel sorry to say that your remarks
will hurt our interests heavily in Bihar. The voters of Bihar are the most
intelligent and they will read your mind better than anyone else in the
country. You will be dubbed an opportunist. Look at Laluji's[former chief
minister Lalu Prasad Yadav] remarks. He praised you because he knows if
you stick to your stand on Jinnah, BJP's loyal voters will shift away from
the party.
Our party leaders also speculate
that your calculation is that if the BJP emerges as a bigger party, you
will be its prime ministerial candidate. What you have said is helping
you emerge as a more acceptable leader in the National Democratic Alliance.
Your remarks are a recognition of the era of coalitions.
But even if this is true, why are
you twisting history? And that too in Pakistan?
Your image is of that a Hindu leader.
Please don't shed that image. India needs somebody to look up with respect
for the security of Hindus.
What you have done, is something
even a Congress leader would think twice before doing. Now, we will watch
your words carefully. Now, we just don't trust any leader. Political leaders
can change anytime and in any manner that suits them.
We are deeply hurt.
Our party is full of Rashtriya Swayamsevak
Sangh trained people. They will revolt against you. If you don't change,
the party will break. The party will disperse. There are many areas in
country where there is not a single home that does not have an RSS sympathiser.
In those areas we will not be able to even move around.
These workers know that Jinnah was
communal and snatched a part of our motherland by misleading the Britishers
and the Congress leaders of that time. The country doesn't believe in your
views on Jinnah.
I am your party's soldier. I want
peace with Pakistan. But I want to stick to my identity of a Hindu. I want
to be proud of being a Hindu. How can the BJP shed its identity of being
a party which cares for Hindus?
If we do, why would anyone join
us or vote for us? Why should he then not join the Congress or the Rashtriya
Janata Dal or even the Communists?
Advaniji, yeh aapne kya kiya, kyon
kiya [what have you done, why]?
Signed
A loyal BJP worker