Author: Swapan Das Gupta
Publication: Free Press Journal
Date: June 13, 2005
URL: http://www.samachar.com/features/130605-features.html
Arazor-sharp memory, particularly
the ability to use legal precedents to full advantage, is what makes a
lawyer tick. For politicians, however, any over-familiarity with history
isn't a professional attribute, at least not when it involves communicating
with an electorate that lives for the present and dreams of the future.
This disconcerting facet of modernity
appears to have escaped the BJP president L.K. Advani. Ever since the Congress-led
UPA Government bared its streak of intolerance, first in Goa, then in Jharkhand
and, finally, in Bihar, it has become customary for the Leader of Opposition
to invoke the dreaded Emergency of 1975-77. "I am reminded of the Emergency"
has become a feature of Advani-speak.
The allusion may well be compelling
but is pertinent to question its efficacy. In just over three weeks, on
June 26, it will be exactly 30 years from the day Indira Gandhi put democracy
on hold, jailed the vast majority of the non-Communist opposition and suspended
civil liberties. Amid a vulgar display of sycophancy and highhandedness,
India was turned into a oneparty, authoritarian state.
For those who were old enough to
remember those terrible 21 months, the Emergency will always be a defining
moment. Apart from the all-pervasive atmosphere of fear and terror which,
of course, ensured that trains ran on time, the Emergency became the occasion
for political goons of the ruling party to use the special powers to settle
personal scores.
It was not merely the rule of law
that was put on hold; the codes of decency were kept in suspended animation.
The Rajmatas of Jaipur and Gwalior were kept in cells with common criminals
and CPI(M) parliamentarian Jyotirmoy Basu singled out for exceptional treatment
because he had the temerity to question the special favours given to the
small car project of the Prime Minister's son.
Even Kishore Kumar was banned from
All India Radio because he had offended someone, somewhere. "Emergency:
an era of discipline" was the cryptic certificate of approval issued by
the senile Bhoodan leader Acharya Vinoba Bhave-a testimonial faithfully
stamped on every postcard and inland letter form.
"The Leader is right, the future
is bright" proclaimed a gigantic hoarding in Delhi's Connaught Place, sponsored
by a "progressive" weekly from Bombay. From the smoke-emitting rear of
the Capital's threewheeler taxis Indians were reassured that "The nation
is on the move." And Congress president D.K. Barooah announced matterof-
factly that India is Indira.
The CPI organised conventions against
fascism and leftist intellectuals cheered with unconcealed glee as "Hindu
communalist" teachers were rounded up and petty traders forced to sign
statements supporting the 20-point programme of the Prime Minister.
As Education Minister S. Nurul Hasan
purged the arts faculties of undesirables and made Marxism the guiding
philosophy of the social sciences, notables like British Labour Party leader
Michael Foot toured India and gushed over Jawaharlal Nehru's daughter.
The grotesque parody didn't stop
here. After Sanjay Gandhi was anointed Arjun by a fawning N.D. Tiwari,
it was time for fascistic inanities to take over. "Talk less, work more"
became the mantra of the Sanjay brigade.
The Youth Congress has "stolen the
thunder", a proud mother proclaimed. From the sidelines, Ambika Soni, Jagdish
Tytler, Kamal Nath and Lalit Maken cheered. "Sanjay Gandhi's rise to power",
wrote Russi Karanjia in Blitz, "came to us as History's own answer to our
prayers." Other venerable editors like Khushwant Singh agreed.
Much of the grim history of the
Emergency can be pieced together from the two volumes of the Shah Commission
Interim Report, David Selbourne's richly documented An Eye to India and
John Dayal and Ajoy Bose's Delhi Under Emergency.
In addition, Janardhan Thakur's
All the Prime Minister's Men provides riveting pen portraits of the individuals
who propped up Indira Gandhi's tyranny. It's a shame though that most of
these books are either out of print or, in the case of Justice J.C. Shah's
report, conveniently withdrawn from circulation.
The only available account of those
dark days is textbook historian Bipan Chandra's In the Name of Democracy,
an apologist account of Jayaprakash Narayan's perfidy and Indira Gandhi's
compulsions.
However, it is not merely the absence
of available histories that has transformed the experience of the Emergency
into a nonevent for the overwhelming majority of India's under-45s.
There appears to be an unbridgeable
gap between those for whom the Emergency was a political landmark and for
those for whom it is a meaningless shibboleth. There is a discernible absence
of an enduring mythology and political folklore surrounding the Emergency
that spans the generations.
Take the case of George Fernandes,
a politician who is today at the centre of a political storm. For one generation
of politicos, Fernandes is a heroic figure, the man who tormented Indira
Gandhi and who inspired the resistance against authoritarianism.
To another generation, Fernandes
is just another unworthy politician. One generation remembers the handcuffed
chief accused in the Baroda Dynamite Case defiantly proclaiming "The chains
we bear today are the symbols of the entire nation that has been fettered
by dictatorship"; the other generation thinks of the sly insinuations in
the Tehelka videotapes.
In the annals of anti-Congressism-the
thread that binds the regional parties, the followers of Ram Manohar Lohia
and the Hindu nationalists-the Emergency is a lost opportunity. The groundswell
of anger that drove the Congress out of office in 1977 was, first, allowed
to be dissipated.
The Janata Party experiment of 1977-80
was such an unmitigated disaster that Indira Gandhi bounced back with a
vengeance. In the 28 years since the Emergency was lifted, the Congress
has been in power at the Centre for nearly 16 years, enough time to bowdlerise
memory.
Secondly, the dilution of the democratic
momentum after 1977 ensured that no permanent opprobrium was attached to
those who played either junior officers or foot-soldiers of the Emergency.
All regimes after 1977 seemed more than willing to indulge those who ratted
on their colleagues to stay out of jail.
Their re-entry into the orbit of
anti-Congressism ensured a cross-party stake in the promotion of amnesia.
Finally, the Congress quickly grasped that outright authoritarianism would
provoke a backlash. Political power, it felt, could be better held through
the subterfuge of institutions rather than a frontal assault on democracy.
Sonia Gandhi is not taking her cue
from the Emergency. There are enough other shadowy precedents to fall back
on. And, there are enough compliant Governors and civil servants willing
to bend the rules.
Those interested could mull over
the Shah Commission's account of present Election Commissioner Navin Chawla's
conduct during the Emergency. The ghosts of the Emergency have been finally
exorcised.
For this, the Congress must thank
a fatal miscalculation on the other side. In 1977, the drive and energy
of the Janata Party was provided by leaders like Fernandes, Chandra Shekhar,
Subramaniam Swamy and, to a lesser extent, Atal Behari Vajpayee.
Yet, the rewards of victory were
reaped by veterans like Morarji Desai, Jagjivan Ram and Charan Singh, who
were still enmeshed in the battles of the late-1960s. Consequently, the
Janata Government lacked the inspirational aplomb to elevate the anti-
Emergency struggle into folklore.
Its Generals were busy replaying
past battles. Ironically, by the time those who should have got power in
1977 finally grasped the prize 21 years later, they themselves were horribly
dated.
As the bewildered and bemused popular
responses to Advani's invocations of the Emergency indicate, post-dated
cheques can't ever keep pace with changing values. And not when the currency
itself has changed.