Author: Irfan Husain
Publication: Dawn
Date: December 3, 2005
URL: http://www.dawn.com/weekly/mazdak/20051203.htm
MEET Sanno Amra and his wife Champa: a middle-aged
Hindu couple. They live in a small, simple but spotlessly clean home in Karachi's
Punjab Colony.
Until six weeks ago, they lived with their
five children, reasonably content with their lot. Sanno worked as a chauffeur,
and his wife cooked for a family. On October 18, their lives suddenly fell
apart: Champa returned home from work to discover that her three oldest daughters
were missing - Reena (21), Usha (19) and Rima (17) had seemingly vanished
without a trace. This is any parent's worst nightmare, but the couple's woes
had only begun.
After searching frantically for the girls,
they went to the local police station where the SHO put them off without registering
a case. A couple of days later, they met the deputy superintendent of police
for Clifton. This proved to be the only bright spot in the entire tragic episode,
for DSP Raza Shah went out of his way to help. He forced his subordinates
to file an FIR, and his intervention was invaluable in ensuring the safety
of the parents. And just for the record, the MQM 'sector-in- charge' also
lent them his organisation's support.
On October 22, a police FIR for kidnapping
was duly prepared, naming three young men from the neighbourhood as the principal
suspects. Immediately, Sanno and his wife started getting threats from their
neighbours. Earlier they had never had any problems, although they were the
only Hindu family in a predominantly Muslim locality. But now, the same people
were pressuring them to remove the names of the local boys from the FIR.
Within days, they received a package by courier
containing three identical affidavits signed by their daughters, stating that
they had converted to Islam of their own free will. The declaration concluded:
"That since my parents are Hindu and after conversion of my religion,
it is not possible for me to live and pass my life in Hindu system/society
[sic] and therefore, I have decided to live separately..."
According to their affidavits, the girls (now
calling themselves Afshan, Anam and Nida) were living in the hostel of the
Madarsa Taleem-ul-Quran, and were being instructed by a local moulvi. On November
10, a court order directed the police and the administrators of the seminary
to arrange a meeting between the girls and their parents.
When Sanno and Champa finally met their daughters,
they were shocked to see that they were in burqas that concealed them from
head to toe, leaving only their eyes uncovered. The eyes of the youngest girl
were bloodshot from weeping. At this supposedly private meeting, a dour woman
was present throughout as were a moulvi and a couple of cops. In subdued voices
muffled by heavy fabric, the girls said they wanted to stay where they were.
Understandably, the parents are convinced
that their daughters were under pressure. In fact, they simply cannot come
to terms with the notion that their children have not only abandoned them,
but also the faith they grew up in. As far as they are concerned, their daughters
have been brainwashed. Interestingly, the girls have cited "religious
channels on TV" as the reason for their conversion.
Since their daughters left, Sanno and Champa
have not returned to their jobs. They stay at home with Suraj and Arti, their
young son and daughter and wait for news. Apart from their neighbours, they
have also been isolated by their own community. According to Sanno, other
Hindus look down on them because of their girls' apparent conversion. Face,
that most pernicious of Asian values, has been lost.
I spoke to DSP Raza Shah and asked him if
in his opinion, any pressure had been brought to bear on the girls. He was
sure it had been a voluntary conversion, adding that it was very possible
that neighbours might have influenced them. The parents are clear that their
daughters never watched TV in their presence, nor did they ever discuss the
possibility of a conversion. According to Vijay, a relative, twenty girls
from the Hindu community had converted to Islam in the last five years.
Talking to the parents in their simple home,
I could feel their pain and their distress. "We just sit and stare at
each other", Sanno said. "For us, life is over." Above all,
they want the certainty of the knowledge that their daughters did not abandon
them voluntarily. They went back to the madressah recently where they were
refused access to their daughters. "Even if they have become Muslims,
we are still their parents," Champa said tearfully. The moulvi at the
madressah, instead of being sympathetic, invited Sammo and Champa to convert
as well.
What the stricken parents are looking for
is closure: once they are satisfied that their daughters will never come home
again, they will learn to live with their grief. But for this to happen, they
want the girls to be moved to neutral ground like the Edhi orphanage where
they can meet them without the coercive presence of moulvis and cops. But
this request has been turned down by a judge.
Vijay has shared the family's tribulations,
and is understandably bitter. "Mr Jinnah had promised the minorities
equal rights and protection. But it seems his promises were buried with him,"
he maintains. Given the spate of conversions, some voluntary, some forced,
the insecurity among the minorities, especially among Sindhi Hindus, is understandable.
Even if most of these conversions are not
at gunpoint, they still take place in an overpowering environment of religiosity.
Religious programmes on every private and public TV channel must leave an
imprint on young minds. The need to conform at school and college where religion
casts a constant shadow, must exert a subtle influence on non-Muslim students.
And in a society based on faith, the minorities have been marginalized to
the point where they are tempted to convert simply to get ahead in life.
But Sammo and Champa are not concerned with
the larger issues regarding the place and fate of the minorities in Pakistan.
All they want is justice. For them this involves being able to spend time
alone with their beloved daughters, free from pressure and coercion, and to
satisfy themselves that they took this drastic step on their own. Surely in
a state that aspires to General Musharraf's oft-touted ideal of 'enlightened
moderation', this should not be too much to ask for.
